Go to the WP Recipe Maker > Manage > Recipe Fields > Ingredients page and make sure the “Plural” column is enabled at the top. You can then click on the icon to set the plural version of an ingredient.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc83f/cc83f45dc6eb11d9da2e787e8feb8ba2822c3836" alt=""
While setting this, the “Merge” icon (second to the left) can be helpful to merge any existing plural versions into the singular one first.